What's the difference between On the Border's enchilada sauce and canned enchilada sauce?

The starting ingredient. Canned red enchilada sauce is typically built from tomato purée or tomato paste with dried chili powder — it tastes primarily of tomato with spice. The On the Border-style sauce starts with whole dried ancho and guajillo chiles that are toasted and rehydrated. This process produces a sauce that's fruity, earthy, and mildly smoky with minimal tomato presence. The color is a deeper brick-red, and the chile flavor reads as a full, complex flavor rather than hot or sharp. The method takes 25 minutes; the difference on the plate is significant.

Can I use flour tortillas instead of corn?

Technically yes, but you'll get a very different result. Corn tortillas are the traditional and correct choice for enchiladas — their texture holds up to the sauce better and their flavor complements the dried chile sauce directly. Flour tortillas become gummy and starchy when baked under sauce, and they don't have the flavor contrast that makes corn tortillas work. If you must use flour, use small 6-inch flour tortillas and reduce the bake time by 5 minutes. But consider using corn — the texture difference after baking is dramatic.

Why do the corn tortillas crack when I roll them?

They weren't softened enough before rolling. Corn tortillas are brittle at room temperature and will crack under any stress. The fix is either hot oil (the correct method: 5 to 8 seconds per side in ¼ inch of hot oil) or a microwave (45 seconds in a damp paper towel). The oil method produces slightly more pliable tortillas with better flavor; the microwave method is faster and lower-fat. The important thing is to roll the tortillas while still warm — they stiffen quickly as they cool.

Can I make On the Border chicken enchiladas ahead?

Yes — they assemble well up to 24 hours ahead. Assemble fully, cover tightly with plastic wrap, and refrigerate. Remove the dish from the refrigerator 30 minutes before baking to take the chill off, then bake as directed (you may need an extra 5 minutes if starting from cold). The red chile sauce also keeps for 5 days refrigerated or 3 months frozen, making the meal much faster to assemble on a weeknight.

What kind of dried chiles are essential — can I substitute?

Ancho and guajillo are the right chiles and are worth seeking out (most well-stocked grocery stores carry them; Latin markets always do). Anchos are dried poblano peppers — mild, fruity, raisin-like. Guajillos are slightly thinner, more acidic, with better red color. You can use all anchos if guajillos aren't available, but the sauce will be slightly less vibrant. Do not substitute New Mexico chiles for guajillos — they're hotter and the flavor profile is different. Canned chipotle in adobo adds smoke but is a completely different sauce; don't use it here.

How do I know the enchiladas are done?

The cheese should be fully melted, bubbling at the dish's edges (not just on top), and showing a few light brown spots. The sauce at the perimeter will look slightly darker and thickened rather than runny. A 9×13 dish at 375°F typically hits this in 22 to 24 minutes. If the cheese is browning too fast on top before the sauce has thickened, tent the dish loosely with foil for the last 5 minutes.

What's the best cheese combination for these enchiladas?

Monterey Jack for melt (it goes stringy and bubbly) and sharp cheddar for flavor. On the Border uses a similar Monterey Jack and cheddar blend — the Monterey Jack provides that smooth, gooey pull and the cheddar contributes sharpness that the mild Jack lacks on its own. Do not use pre-shredded bagged cheese if you can avoid it — the anti-caking coating prevents it from melting as cleanly. Shred from a block. Chihuahua or Oaxacan cheese are great Mexican alternatives if you want to go more traditional.

On the Border Chicken Enchiladas Recipe — Copycat with Homemade Red Chile Sauce

Name: On the Border Chicken Enchiladas
Prep time: 30 min
Cook time: 40 min
Total time: 1 h 10 min
Yield: 4
Cuisine: Mexican
Ingredients: For the red chile sauce:; 4 dried ancho chiles, stemmed and seeded; 3 dried guajillo chiles, stemmed and seeded; 4 garlic cloves, peeled; ½ medium white onion, quartered; 2 cups chicken broth; 1 tbsp tomato paste; 1 tsp ground cumin; 1 tsp dried Mexican oregano (or regular dried oregano); ½ tsp fine salt, plus more to taste; ½ tsp sugar; 1 tbsp vegetable oil; For the chicken filling:; 1½ lbs boneless, skinless chicken thighs; 2 cups chicken broth; 1 tsp chili powder; 1 tsp ground cumin; 1 tsp garlic powder; ½ tsp onion powder; ½ tsp fine salt; For assembly:; 12 corn tortillas (6-inch); ¼ cup vegetable oil, for softening tortillas; 2 cups (8 oz) shredded Monterey Jack cheese, divided; 1 cup (4 oz) shredded sharp cheddar cheese, divided; For serving:; Sour cream; Diced white onion; Fresh cilantro; Lime wedges

One of the most-searched sit-down-chain copycat recipes isn’t the Cheesecake Factory’s brown bread or Olive Garden’s breadsticks. It’s three rolled enchiladas on a plate — specifically, On the Border’s chicken enchiladas, smothered in a brick-red dried-chile sauce and buried under a blanket of melted Monterey Jack and cheddar.

People kept searching because the sauce is hard to get right without knowing the method.

Why the Sauce Is Everything

Most copycat recipes and most home versions of Tex-Mex enchiladas reach for canned red enchilada sauce or a slurry of chili powder and tomato paste. The result tastes thin and one-dimensional — you get hot and salty, but not the earthy, slightly fruity depth that On the Border’s version has.

The difference is starting with whole dried chiles instead of powder.

Dried ancho chiles (the dried form of the poblano) bring a dark, raisin-like sweetness. Dried guajillos add the brick-red color and a mild tartness. Toast them briefly in a dry skillet — 20 to 30 seconds per side — and they transform: the heat unlocks the natural oils and sugars, converting the raw bitter edge into something genuinely fragrant and complex. Rehydrate in hot water, blend smooth with garlic and broth, fry the sauce briefly in oil to deepen it. Twenty-five minutes total. This is what makes the recipe worth making.

The Other Step Most Recipes Skip

Dip the corn tortillas in hot oil before rolling. This is not optional.

Corn tortillas are brittle at room temperature and crack immediately under any stress. A brief dip in ¼ inch of hot oil — 5 to 8 seconds per side — softens them just enough to roll cleanly and keeps them from absorbing too much sauce during baking. The result is an enchilada with a saucy, tender exterior and a filling that stays intact rather than a wet, collapsed tube.

The microwave-in-a-damp-paper-towel method works as an alternative. But the oil dip is faster, and the tortillas stay pliable longer.

More Great Tex-Mex and Mexican-American Dishes

Chili’s Chicken Enchilada Soup — On the Border’s Tex-Mex neighbor in casual dining: Chili’s creamy red broth soup with pulled chicken, roasted corn, and black beans is one of the most-copied soups from any American chain
Carrabba’s Pollo Rosa Maria — another endlessly-searched casual-dining copycat, a prosciutto-and-fontina-stuffed chicken breast finished in a lemon-butter sauce
Rao’s Marinara Sauce — another “it’s only four ingredients but the technique is everything” sauce that people search obsessively to replicate at home

On the Border is a trademark of its owner, used here only to describe the dish this recipe recreates. This is an independent copycat written in our own words — Copycat Spices is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by On the Border.

On the Border Chicken Enchiladas

Shop the tools