What makes Pillsbury Christmas sugar cookies taste different from regular homemade sugar cookies?

Three things. First, the fat: Pillsbury uses vegetable shortening (palm and palm kernel oil), not butter. Shortening has a higher melting point and no water content, which means the cookies spread less and stay puffier — the Pillsbury texture is soft and slightly cakey, not crisp or thin. Most homemade sugar cookies use all butter, which spreads more and crisps up. Second, the starch: the original uses modified cornstarch, which tenderizes the crumb and slows staling. Cornstarch in this recipe does the same thing. Third, the flavoring: the store version uses vanilla plus butter extract — a mild, mellow sweetness that's different from the brighter taste of pure vanilla. If you've ever eaten a Pillsbury cookie and thought it tasted 'rounder' or 'more bakery-like' than your own recipe, the butter extract is part of why.

What is butter extract and where do I find it?

Butter extract is a concentrated flavoring made from real butter or imitation butter compounds — it adds a mild, sweet, buttery note without any actual fat. It's what gives store-bought cookies, frosting, and cake mixes their characteristic 'bakery' flavor. Look for it in the baking aisle near vanilla extract; Watkins and McCormick both make one that's widely available at grocery stores, Walmart, and Amazon. If you can't find it, the cookies still taste good — just use 2½ teaspoons of vanilla total instead of vanilla plus butter extract. The butter extract isn't the whole flavor profile, but it is what differentiates this recipe from a standard sugar cookie.

Can I use all butter instead of shortening?

You can, but the cookies won't taste or behave like Pillsbury. All-butter sugar cookies spread more in the oven (butter melts at a lower temperature and releases water as steam, which flattens the cookie), and they go from soft to crisp as they cool. You'll end up with a very good, buttery sugar cookie — just a different animal from the puffed, soft Pillsbury-style cookie. If you want to avoid shortening but still get some of the texture benefit, substitute the ¼ cup of butter with an additional ¼ cup of cream cheese (softened); it has a similar fat-to-water structure to shortening and produces a notably soft cookie without the processed flavor. The cream cheese version won't taste quite the same as Pillsbury but will be soft and hold its shape well.

How do I get the colored sanding sugar to stick evenly to the outside of the log?

Three steps: (1) Make sure the dough is slightly tacky, not too cold. Freshly mixed dough is perfect; if the dough was refrigerated before shaping, let it sit at room temperature for 5 minutes so the surface is just slightly soft. (2) Pour the sanding sugar in a thin line on a piece of wax paper, then roll the dough log over it rather than packing sugar onto the log — rolling distributes the sugar more evenly and presses it in gently. (3) After rolling, press the sides and ends gently with your hands to embed the sugar without brushing it off. Refrigerating immediately after coating helps the sugar set against the dough surface — by the time you slice, it will be firmly attached. If any spots are thin, dip those sections briefly in the sugar bowl before wrapping.

How thin should I slice the cookies, and what knife should I use?

Slice them ¼ inch thick. Thinner (⅛ inch) and they bake too quickly into crispy wafers — not the Pillsbury texture. Thicker (⅜ inch or more) and the centers stay doughy before the edges are done. A ¼-inch slice is about the diameter of a pencil laid on its side — not a precise measurement, but easy to eyeball once you have the rhythm. Use a sharp chef's knife (not serrated) and one clean downward press per cookie — no sawing. A sawing motion scrapes the sanding sugar off the edges and distorts the circle shape. Wipe the knife clean every 6–8 slices so sanding sugar doesn't build up and pull the cookie sideways. If the log crumbles or breaks while slicing, it was too cold; let it sit at room temperature for 2 minutes and try again.

My cookies spread and went flat — what went wrong?

Almost always one of three causes: (1) Not enough shortening or too much butter. The shortening ratio is what prevents spreading; if you substituted more butter for the shortening, the cookies will spread. (2) The dough wasn't chilled long enough. An underchilled log means soft fat that melts immediately in the oven before the structure sets. Two hours is the minimum; overnight is better. (3) The baking sheet was warm from a previous batch. Always start with a cool pan; a hot pan starts melting the fat before the oven air does, causing spreading before the cookies set. If spreading is a persistent issue, add 1 extra tablespoon of flour to the dough — it stiffens the structure without meaningfully changing the flavor.

How long do the unbaked logs keep in the refrigerator, and can I freeze them?

Refrigerator: wrapped tightly in plastic, up to 5 days — the dough stays ready to slice and bake any time. This is the whole appeal of the refrigerated cookie format: mix once, bake in small batches all week. Freezer: up to 3 months. Wrap the plastic-wrapped log in a layer of aluminum foil (double wrap prevents freezer burn and protects the sugar coating). To bake from frozen: let the log thaw in the refrigerator overnight or at room temperature for 20–30 minutes, then slice and bake as directed. Don't bake from fully frozen — the outside cookies will brown before the centers defrost. Baked cookies keep at room temperature in an airtight container for 5–7 days.

Can I add icing or additional decorations on top?

Yes — and it's the easiest upgrade. The Pillsbury holiday shape cookies come with designs already baked in; at home, you add the decoration after baking. Wait until the cookies are fully cool, then pipe royal icing or use premade cookie icing tubes (Wilton makes them in red, green, and white) to add stars, stripes, dots, or outlines. Simple white royal icing with red or green sanding sugar on top is the quickest approach and looks cleanest. Alternatively, brush the tops lightly with corn syrup or simple syrup immediately after baking (while still warm) and press seasonal sprinkles or edible glitter directly into the surface — the surface is slightly tacky for about 30 seconds after the oven. For a minimal approach, the colored sanding sugar edge already gives the cookies their holiday identity without any additional decoration.

Pillsbury Christmas Shape Sugar Cookies

Name: Pillsbury Christmas Shape Sugar Cookies
Prep time: PT20M(plus 2-Hchill)
Cook time: 12 min
Total time: 32 min
Yield: 28–32 cookies
Cuisine: American
Ingredients: For the dough:; 2 cups (250g) all-purpose flour, spooned and leveled; 2 tablespoons cornstarch; ½ teaspoon baking powder; ¼ teaspoon fine salt; ½ cup (96g) vegetable shortening (Crisco solid), at room temperature; ¼ cup (½ stick / 56g) unsalted butter, softened to room temperature; ¾ cup (150g) granulated sugar; 1 large egg, at room temperature; 2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract; ½ teaspoon butter extract (Watkins or McCormick; see FAQ for substitutions); ¼ teaspoon almond extract; For coating the logs:; 3 tablespoons red sanding sugar (coarse crystal sugar, not regular granulated); 3 tablespoons green sanding sugar

Prep: 20 minutes | Chill: 2+ hours | Bake: 12–14 minutes | Makes: 28–32 cookies

Pillsbury Ready to Bake Christmas Shape cookies run about $4.50 for 24 cookies. This recipe makes 28–32 for about $5–7 in ingredients — a similar per-cookie cost, but with real vanilla, real butter mixed in, and a dough that stores in your refrigerator for up to 5 days so you can bake a few batches over the whole holiday week.

The Two Things That Make It Pillsbury

1. Shortening, not all butter. The original product uses palm and palm kernel oil — commercial shortening. Shortening has a higher melting point than butter and no water content. When you bake a shortening-based cookie, the fat doesn’t melt and spread before the structure sets; the cookie stays puffed, soft, and pale. Substitute all butter and you get a delicious sugar cookie — a thinner, crisper, more golden one that’s nothing like Pillsbury. This recipe uses a 2:1 shortening-to-butter ratio: enough shortening to hold the shape and produce the soft bite, enough butter to actually taste good.

2. Butter extract. The Pillsbury flavor isn’t just vanilla — it’s vanilla plus a mild butter note that reads as “round and bakery-like.” Butter extract (Watkins or McCormick, baking aisle, ~$3) adds that quality in a quarter teaspoon. It’s subtle, but it’s what separates “homemade sugar cookie” from “tastes like Pillsbury.” If you can’t find it, the recipe still works; just add an extra ½ teaspoon of vanilla.

The Slice-and-Bake Log: Why It Works for Home Baking

The pre-cut refrigerator cookie format was invented partly for convenience and partly for consistent results. A chilled log of dough cuts cleanly into even rounds, bakes evenly, and produces cookies that hold their shape without requiring cold rolling, flour-dusted cutters, or re-chilling between cut sessions. The sanding sugar edge does triple duty: it looks festive, adds a slight crunch to the otherwise soft exterior, and forms a visual seam that distinguishes these as “holiday” cookies without any icing or decoration.

The method: shape → coat → chill → slice → bake. The chill is mandatory. Unchill the dough and the slices will be soft, will stick to the knife, and will spread in the oven before the structure sets. Two hours minimum; four is better. The logs keep refrigerated for 5 days and frozen for 3 months, so you can mix once and bake fresh batches at any point during the holiday season.

Baking Cue: What “Done” Looks Like

Pillsbury cookies are intentionally pale and soft — not golden, not crisp. The visual cue for done is subtle: the very outer edge of each cookie will look matte and set while the center still looks slightly shiny and underdone. That’s the moment to pull them. They’ll be soft to the touch for the first 5 minutes out of the oven; that’s expected. By the time they cool to room temperature (10–12 more minutes), they’ll be set to the characteristic Pillsbury softness — slightly springy, not doughy.

If they come out crisp or thin: the shortening ratio was off, or the dough wasn’t chilled enough, or you sliced too thick. If the centers stay doughy after cooling: the slices were too thick (closer to ½ inch than ¼ inch) or the oven runs cool. A ¼-inch slice at 350°F in a calibrated oven is the reference point.

Color Variations

The classic is red-and-green; you can use any sanding sugar color for any holiday:

Halloween: orange and black sanding sugar
Valentine’s Day: red and pink
Fourth of July: red, white (plain sugar), and blue
Mixed batch: split each log into thirds and coat with three colors for a rainbow assortment

Sanding sugar (large crystal) stays visible and crunchy on the edge; standard granulated sugar dissolves in the oven and disappears. Both work for the coating but sanding sugar is the one that looks like the store version.

Holiday Gift Packaging

These travel well and are a natural gift item. Let them cool completely, then layer in a holiday tin with parchment paper between layers. A tin of 24 cookies (one batch) looks like the store product but is noticeably fresher. Unfrosted, they’re shelf-stable in a tin for 5–7 days; no refrigeration needed for gifting over a weekend. For a hostess gift, a double batch (two red + two green logs) can yield 60+ cookies — enough for a tin to take and a bag to leave at home.

Related Holiday Baking

For more iconic Christmas sweets made from scratch: Lofthouse Frosted Sugar Cookies are the grocery-store bakery equivalent — thick, cakey, and frosted; Pillsbury Crescent Rolls cover the other half of the Doughboy’s holiday table contribution; Nestlé Toll House Chocolate Chip Cookies are the original American cookie the fridge-dough format adapted. Little Debbie Christmas Tree Cakes are the other December grocery-store tradition worth making at home.

Pillsbury is a trademark of its owner, used here only to describe the dish this recipe recreates. This is an independent copycat written in our own words — Copycat Spices is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Pillsbury.

Pillsbury Christmas Shape Sugar Cookies

Shop the tools